Paper Summary 08

Assigned paper:

Safi, K., & Kerth, G. (2004). A comparative analysis of specialization and extinction risk in temperate‐zone bats. Conservation biology, 18(5), 1293-1303. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.2004.00155.x

Instructions:

The paper summaries should be no longer than one page (single spaced using a 12-point font). References should be included with the report but do not count towards the total length. The following points should be covered (not necessarily in the order given):

  • What is/are the issue(s) addressed by the paper?
  • What is the underlying research approach taken by the paper (e.g., a manipulative experiment, a correlational study, a theoretical model, a literature review, etc.)?
  • What are the main results and what conclusions are expected to be drawn from the paper?
  • How much confidence in the obtained results are implied by the author(s)?
  • Is this confidence justified in your opinion?
    • were the authors scrupulous in discussing their results?
    • were there any weaknesses or limitations in the approach used by the authors?
    • can you think of an alternative interpretation not discussed by the authors?

Submission: It is expected that the assignment be submitted via Canvas as a word document or PDF (your choice). Paper summaries submitted by email will not be accepted unless agreed upon beforehand with the instructor.